Comment threads should be interleaved in the New UI
Project Member Reported by email@example.com, Jan 29 2018
Affected Version: 2.15-rc2-2157-g1438975847 What steps will reproduce the problem? 1. Create a new change 2. Get a reviewer to leave comments on the change 3. Respond to reviewer comments I would expect the comments to be interleaved on a change's details page, which each new response being part of the same section like so: file abc.xyz: - Reviewer (line 1) comment 1 - Author response 1 - Reviewer comment 2 - Author response 2 ... - Reviewer (line 23) comment 1 - Author response 1 ... Instead, the thread is separated by each commenter's group of responses in a new section, like so: Reviewer: file abc.xyz: - (line 1) comment 1 - (line 23) comment 1 Author: file abc.xyz: - (line 1) response 1 - (line 23) response 1 Reviewer: file abc.xyz: - (line 1) comment 2 - (line 23) comment 2 Author: file abc.xyz: - (line 1) response 2 - (line 23) response 2 ... This makes it very difficult to follow a conversation on a change without clicking into the thread itself and going to the file and patchset containing the comment.
Jan 29 2018,
Feb 22 2018,
Mar 15 2018,
Mar 16 2018,
Issue 9720 has been merged into this issue.
Sign in to add a comment