HQP Scores Change Dramatically Adding Scheme to Input
Reported by
teo8...@gmail.com,
Jun 26 2018
|
||||
Issue descriptionUserAgent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/67.0.3396.87 Safari/537.36 Steps to reproduce the problem: Let's say I have an URL in my history that I have visited plenty of times, that is: http://somedomain.com/foo-keyword-bar.html and I want to quickly find it without remembering and typing the whole url. Try entering the following inputs into the omnibox and compare the results: (without quotes) 1. "https://somedomain.com keyword" 2. "somedomain.com keyword" (note: for the second one, after you have typed the domain, by default the omnibox may suggest you "search somedomain.com for:", so hit Backspace to go back to just "somedomain.com" and keep typing. I don't want to do a search within the website, I want to go directly to an url that I know is in my history) What is the expected behavior? Both cases should yield the same exact result: the url http://somedomain.com/foo-keyword-bar.html should appear in the autocomplete suggested results, perhaps among other results if any. What went wrong? The expected behavior happens in case (2), but NOT in case (1). That's stupid and makes no sense. There's no reason why the two should behave differently. What else can I mean by "https://somedomain.com [A F***ING WHITESPACE] keyword" if not "an url that contains/starts with 'https://somedomain.com' and also contains the substring 'keyword'"? I don't know if the reasoning here is: "This starts with 'https://' so it must be a full url, so we only match urls that begin with the substring 'https://somedomain.com[WHITESPACE]keyword" but if that is the case then it's stupid, because a domain name cannot contain spaces. If I was typing "https://somedomain.com/foo keyword" then the behavior would make sense. Did this work before? N/A Chrome version: 67.0.3396.87 Channel: n/a OS Version: Flash Version:
,
Jun 28 2018
Able to reproduce the issue on Mac 10.13.3, Win-10 and Ubuntu 17.10 using chrome reported version #67.0.3396.99 and latest canary #69.0.3474.0. This is a non-regression issue as it is observed from M60 old builds. Hence, marking it as untriaged to get more inputs from dev team. Thanks...!!
,
Jun 28 2018
Thanks for the report!
,
Jun 28 2018
This is weird. The scoring seems to change a lot when you add a scheme/protocol. Clarifying summary line.
,
Jul 14
I might be wrong, but I don't think this has anything to do with score, but rather with either considering the space as a separator, or url-encoding it and considering it as a character in the domain name. Here are the outputs of chrome://omnibox with the two searches. Note that when typing the url with the protocol, the space shows up encoded as "%20" everywhere. You don't see the "%20" at all when typing just the domain name. (BTW in my original report I sometimes typed "http://" and sometimes "https://" but that was a mistake in typing the report, not when doing the tests or facing the issue in real life. I should always read "http://" or always "https://" in all cases consistently.) ==================== CASE 1 ===================== Enter omnibox input text: http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori Input parameters: Prevent inline autocomplete In keyword mode Current page context: Display parameters: Show incomplete results Show all details Show results per provider, not just merged results cursor position = 39 elapsed time = 1ms all providers done = false host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i58&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✗ 0 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✗ 0 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false cursor position = 39 elapsed time = 2ms all providers done = false host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i58&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false cursor position = 39 elapsed time = 129ms all providers done = true host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i58&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✔ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: true should_prefetch: false HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryURL url-what-you-typed 1203 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori/ http://ricette.giallozafferano.it%20fiori ✗ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✔ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: true should_prefetch: false ============================================= =========================== CASE 2 ======================== Enter omnibox input text: ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori Input parameters: Prevent inline autocomplete In keyword mode Current page context: Display parameters: Show incomplete results Show all details Show results per provider, not just merged results cursor position = 32 elapsed time = 1ms all providers done = false host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false cursor position = 32 elapsed time = 1ms all providers done = false host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✗ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: false should_prefetch: false cursor position = 32 elapsed time = 129ms all providers done = true host = ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori has isTypedHost = false Combined results. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ Google Search https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&oq=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✔ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: true should_prefetch: false HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Results for individual providers. Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info HistoryQuick history-url 1302 ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✗ ✗ Ricetta Fiori di zucca ripieni di speck e mozzarella - La Ricetta di GialloZafferano https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html https://ricette.giallozafferano.it/Fiori-di-zucca-ripieni-di-speck-e-mozzarella.html ✔ ✗ 1 ✔ 0 last visit: 0 hours ago typed count: 0 visit count: 3 Provider Type Relevance Contents Can Be Default Starred Description URL Fill Into Edit Inline Autocompletion Del Prev Tran Done Associated Keyword Keyword Duplicates Additional Info Search search-what-you-typed 1300 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✔ ✗ https://www.google.es/search?q=ricette.giallozafferano.it+fiori&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 ricette.giallozafferano.it fiori ✗ ✗ 5 ✔ google.es 0 relevance_from_server: true should_prefetch: false ============================================
,
Jul 14
And note that in case 1 the visited URL does not appear at all in the results, it's not that it appears with a lower score. |
||||
►
Sign in to add a comment |
||||
Comment 1 by viswa.karala@chromium.org
, Jun 26 2018