New issue
Advanced search Search tips

Issue 806468 link

Starred by 2 users
Status: Available
Owner: ----
Components:
EstimatedDays: ----
NextAction: ----
OS: Windows
Pri: 3
Type: Bug



Sign in to add a comment

SVG <image> should honor pointer-events="painted" on transparent areas

Reported by paul.leb...@gmail.com, Jan 27 2018 
UserAgent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/63.0.3239.132 Safari/537.36

Steps to reproduce the problem:
Try the following test case:

https://jsfiddle.net/avf5bbqa/2/

<svg width="400" height="400">
  <a id="blue">
    <rect x="0" y="0" width="200" height="400" fill="skyblue"/>
  </a>
  <a id="red">
    <image x="100" y="100" width="200" height="200"
           image-rendering="pixelated"
           xlink:href=""/>
  </a>

</svg>

function click(evt) {
  console.log("Clicked on " + evt.target.parentNode.id);
}

document.getElementById("blue").addEventListener("click", click);
document.getElementById("red").addEventListener("click", click);

What is the expected behavior?
Clicking on the part of the blue rect that is visible through the hole in the red image, should produce the console output "Clicked on blue"

What went wrong?
Displays "Clicked on red".

The SVG 1.1 and SVG 2 draft specs state the following:

    For raster images, ... [snip} ...

    - The value visiblePainted means that the raster image can receive events anywhere
      within the bounds of the image if any pixel from the raster image which is under
      the pointer is not fully transparent, with the additional requirement that the
      ‘visibility’ property is set to visible.
    - The value painted means that the raster image can receive events anywhere within
      the bounds of the image if any pixel from the raster image which is under the
      pointer is not fully transparent. The value of the ‘visibility’ property does
      not affect event processing.

So the "visiblePainted" and "painted" should result in fully transparent pixels being considered the same as if they were clipped out.

Did this work before? N/A 

Does this work in other browsers? No
 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=311942

Chrome version: 63.0.3239.132  Channel: n/a
OS Version: 6.1 (Windows 7, Windows Server 2008 R2)
Flash Version:

Comment 1 by f...@opera.com, Jan 27 2018 

The specs also say this (just above the bullet list quoted above): 

> For raster images, hit-testing is either performed on a whole-image basis
> (i.e., the rectangular area for the image is one of the determinants for
> whether the image receives the event) or on a per-pixel basis (i.e., the
> alpha values for pixels under the pointer help determine whether the image
> receives the event):

(excerpt from SVG2, SVG 1.1 has roughly - if not exactly - the same text)

I would expect implementations in general to pick the "whole-image" option rather than the "per-pixel" one - primarily to avoid having to access the pixel data of a raster image (which may require readbacks and what not). And let's face it: "whole-image" also leads to a much simpler implementation. It's also consistent with how <html:img> works.

Comment 2 by f...@opera.com, Jan 27 2018 

(FWIW, I realize that the section I quoted can be read to support your interpretation.)

Comment 3 Deleted

Comment 4 by paul.leb...@gmail.com, Jan 27 2018 

I took that paragraph to be referring to the fact that some of the pointer-events values require pixel level access (visiblePainted and painted), and some don't (all the rest).  It didn't seem like they were saying that they had the choice. :)

The two options we are talking about specifically mention pixels:

  "if any pixel from the raster image which is under the pointer is not fully transparent"

whereas the rest don't.  They talk about "the rectangular area of the image".

Comment 5 by paul.leb...@gmail.com, Jan 27 2018 

Related spec issue here: https://github.com/w3c/svgwg/issues/322

Comment 6 by f...@opera.com, Jan 29 2018

Labels: -Pri-2 Pri-3
Status: Available (was: Unconfirmed)
Implementers always choose the interpretation that fits them best... ;-). (I recall this requirement from way back, when we punted on it for the same reason as now but potentially because of different underlying reasons. My recollection was that the spec text had been made more lenient between 1.1 and 1.1SE, but maybe that's not the case.)
►

Sign in to add a comment